What happens during an audit of trust accounts?



To avoid trust accounting violations and be ready for a trust audit, keep a ledger for every client, never mix firm and client money, never let a client balance go negative, reconcile your trust account three ways every month, and keep every bank statement, deposit record and disbursement record for as long as your state requires. A firm that does those things consistently is already prepared for an audit.
Being selected for a trust account audit can be stressful, but knowing what happens during the audit, what auditors ask for, and where firms usually go wrong takes most of the anxiety out of the process.
What Happens During an Audit of Trust Accounts?
A trust account audit is a review of your firm’s trust accounting records by your state bar or its auditors to confirm client funds are handled under the state’s version of ABA Model Rule 1.15. Audits can be random, or triggered by a cause such as a trust account overdraft notice from your bank or a client complaint. The process varies by state, but it generally follows these stages. The examples below are from New Jersey’s random audit program.
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Notice | Notices are usually mailed. In New Jersey, they typically arrive 10 days to two weeks before the audit date. Random selection doesn’t depend on firm size or history, so a firm can be audited more than once or never. |
| 2. Records request | The auditor asks for trust records covering a set period. New Jersey random audits typically cover the two years before the audit date. |
| 3. Questionnaire | The auditor collects information about how the firm keeps its books and handles client funds. |
| 4. Review | The auditor tests reconciliations, client ledgers, deposits and disbursements, and lists any recordkeeping deficiencies. Audits can be in person or mail-in and may take several days. |
| 5. Findings | The firm receives a list of deficiencies. In New Jersey, minor deficiencies typically must be corrected within 45 days. Major problems can be referred to the Office of Attorney Ethics. |
For in-person audits, the attorney may not have to attend, but someone who knows the firm’s books and can answer questions must be available. Failing to produce records or to appear for an audit can lead to disciplinary action.
What Records Do Trust Account Auditors Ask For?
Expect to produce:
- Trust bank statements
- Canceled checks or check images
- Deposit slips and records of wires and electronic transfers
- Receipts and disbursements journals
- Individual client ledgers
- The trust check register
- Monthly three-way reconciliation reports
- Engagement and fee agreements, settlement statements and other client documents that support trust transactions
Record retention periods vary by state. The ABA Model Rule calls for five years, and some states, including New Jersey, require seven.
How Do I Prepare for a Trust Account Audit?
The best audit prep happens every month, not the week the notice arrives. Use this checklist:
- Reconcile three ways every month. Bank statement, trust register, and the total of client ledgers must agree. Save each signed reconciliation report.
- Review every client ledger. Look for negative balances, old balances that should have been disbursed, and transactions without a client or matter.
- Match every deposit and disbursement to support. Each one should tie to a deposit slip, check, wire confirmation, invoice, or settlement statement.
- Confirm earned fees were moved promptly. Earned money left in trust is commingling.
- Resolve stale and unclaimed balances. Follow your state’s process for unclaimed trust funds.
- Organize records by month and client so you can produce them quickly, in paper or digital form.
- Know your state’s rules for reconciliation frequency, record retention, required account names, and electronic payments.
- Name an audit contact. Choose who will work with the auditor and make sure they know the books.
- Fix and document errors now. A documented correction looks very different to an auditor than an unexplained difference. See how to fix a trust accounting mistake.
How to Avoid Trust Accounting Mistakes
Most trust accounting violations come from the same handful of mistakes:
| Mistake | How to avoid it |
|---|---|
| Commingling firm and client money | Keep separate trust and operating accounts, and move earned fees out of trust promptly. |
| Negative client balances | Never disburse more than a client has in trust. A negative ledger means another client’s money was used. |
| Disbursing before funds clear | Wait for deposits, especially settlement checks, to clear before paying out. |
| Paying firm expenses or processing fees from trust | Pay all firm bills and card processing fees from operating. |
| Skipping monthly reconciliation | Run and save a three-way reconciliation every month. |
| Transactions without a client or matter | Tag every trust deposit and withdrawal to a client ledger. See how to record trust deposits. |
| Taking fees before they are earned | Withdraw only earned fees, after billing or notice where required. See when you can take money out of a trust account. |
| Unexplained adjustments | Correct errors with documented reversing entries; never plug numbers to make a reconciliation balance. |
| Using personal or non-legal software | Use trust accounting software that keeps client ledgers and blocks overdrafts. |
The most serious violation is misappropriating client funds, even by accident. Many of the mistakes above lead to it. See also how to maintain trust account compliance and the real cost of non-compliance.
What Triggers a Trust Account Audit?
- Random selection under a state’s random audit program
- Overdraft notices. Many states require banks to report trust account overdrafts to the bar.
- Client complaints about missing or delayed funds
- Disciplinary investigations or other red flags
How CosmoLex Helps You Stay Audit-Ready
CosmoLex includes built-in trust accounting that keeps a ledger for every client, blocks transactions that would overdraw a client’s balance, and produces three-way reconciliation and trust reports in a few clicks. Because billing, trust, and business accounting are in one system, every transaction posts once to the right place, so the records an auditor asks for are ready when you need them. Learn more in our IOLTA and trust accounting guide.
Book a demo to see CosmoLex trust accounting in action.
FAQ
How do law firms avoid trust accounting violations and prepare for a trust audit?
Keep a ledger for every client, never commingle firm and client funds, never let a client balance go negative, reconcile three ways every month, document every transaction, and keep records for as long as your state requires.
What happens during an audit of trust accounts?
The firm receives notice, produces trust records for a set period, completes a questionnaire, and the auditor reviews reconciliations, client ledgers, deposits, and disbursements. The firm then receives a list of deficiencies to correct; serious problems can be referred for discipline.
How do I prepare for a trust account audit?
Make sure monthly three-way reconciliations are complete and saved, review every client ledger for negative or stale balances, match every transaction to supporting documents, organize records by month and client, and name someone who knows the books to work with the auditor.
What are the most common trust accounting mistakes?
Commingling funds, negative client balances, disbursing before deposits clear, paying firm expenses or processing fees from trust, skipping monthly reconciliation, and withdrawing fees before they are earned.
How long should law firms keep trust account records?
It depends on the state. The ABA Model Rule calls for five years, and some states, such as New Jersey, require seven years.
References
